Anime List + Web

[Robo]

I use AnimeSeason.com, have been for years, works great.

If your an ancient anime watcher who has "seen it all" and looking for something new!
I would recommend IS:Infinite Stratos, its a new anime (only ep 2) and its a mix between action, comedy, and drama. (Harem btw) its set in the future where mech-suits (not full body, fairly unique) were created, these "mech-suits" are know as "the IS systems" in which for unexplained reasons only women can pilot. The world is at peace so the IS system is strictly used for sporting competition. There is only one school in the world dedicated to training IS pilots, furthermore there is only 1 male in the world who can use the IS system, the main character who is attending this "all girl but 1" school to use the IS system. So far I would say it is interesting.

So far thats the only "new" anime I have been drawn to, some of my favorite classics are as follows for those of you who haven't seen the "must-watch" animes. I broke them into categories.
*The themes bellow do not always describe the ENTIRE anime, but in my opinion, the majority*
Action/Mystery: Pandora Hearts <-- reminds me of .hack, IDK why...
Mystery-Action: .//Hack
Action-Comedy: Fairy Tail <--- similar to One Piece, but has unique spin
OLD-Comedy-action: Ranma 1/2 <--- a CLASSIC & VERY long, a meh anime
Action-Comedy: mostly action: Hunter X Hunter, though it is childish at first, it gets really nice. DBZ fans!!
Comedy-Life-drama: Chobits (mild action)
Comedy-Life: Lucky Star
Comedy-Drama: Nagasarete Airantou (very funny, nice anime, cute)
Action-ACTION: Claymore (as said already...)
Action-Comedy: Soul Eater (it stars off childish, though it is funny, it gets REALLY intense latter on)
Mystery-Action: Hard to categorize this but... 07-Ghost.... Very.....Unique...anime...
Comedy-Action: Kenichi The Mightiest Disciple <-- its interesting, kinda reminds me of Ranma a bit.
Horror-Action-Comedy: Gakuen Mokushiroku- High School of the Dead
Mystery-Horror: Death Note (Classic, its all a mystery unfolding as 2 masterminds duke it out, lives on the line)
Comedy-Action-life: Gokusen (A high-ranked gang member tries to be a teacher in a delinquent school)
Comedy-Drama: Fruits Basket (Cute story, very funny too)
Gore-Horror-Action: Elfen Lied (VERY bloody action anime, kinda hard to watch)
Action-Comedy: Druaga no Tou (reminds me of .hack, though very nice story, some drama too)
Horror-Comedy-Action: Peacemaker Kurogane (didnt like ending but up-till its good)
Action-Comedy: Hitman Reborn (Starts off childish but gets intense later on)
Action-Drama: Fate Stay Night (AMAZING anime, one of my favorites, starts slow but gets good)
Action-Drama: Kurokami The Animation (AMAZING anime, kinda predictable but still great)

Hope this helps, have fun all!

[Mistereo]

I second IS:Infinite Stratos one of the good new anime that is out.

[Elenora]

yup IS is purrty good

[farcus]

no bleach?

[Robo]

Ok I lost faith in bleach (manga) has gone to HELL (literally) and the latest arch (anime & manga) where they can steal the "existence" of "objects" is just stupid...long term fan I was but as the series changed so did my views on that trash...*rant*